From autonomy

Is politically invented “risk” in homebirth defining the rights of childbearing women? (Part 1)

I’ve held off commenting on the now notorious, and as of yet unpublished, Wax homebirth meta-analysis and the ensuing hullabaloo because I had wanted to keep negative birth politics to a minimum here on my blog.  Then, the viscerally disturbing Lancet editorial came out a few weeks ago and WHOA. We’re starting to see some of the anti-homebirth roots coming to the surface.  It’s time for each and every inspired individual to speak up.

Joseph Wax MD, lead author of the Wax meta-analysis

A number of smart science minds have already broken down the methodological flaws of the Wax meta-analysis into comprehensible nuts and bolts so I won’t expound upon its junk science here,  suffice it to say the authors’ conclusion of a tripled increase in neonatal mortality in homebirth is a gross misrepresentation of the actual data. Based on the ongoing anti-homebirth and anti-midwife smear campaign, one might reasonably surmise the misleading conclusion was crafted to incite more anti-homebirth rhetoric among the medical community.

Read more

labor walking

Women feeling "safe" in a hospital birth

People in the “Women should birth where they feel safest.”  You hear this a lot in the birth change movement.  Midwives, doulas, CBEs, advocates and allies — we all support women’s choice in birth place.  Most women in this country give birth in hospitals.  Are women going there to birth babies because they truly feel safe there?  What ingredients = feeling safe?

There’s the standard, albeit superficial, ‘healthy mom, healthy baby’ wrap offered up by women to partners and sometimes themselves, but what lies beyond the cheery one-liners?  Where does emotional safety lie? Normal birth is so hidden and rare in our culture that the average woman may never even encounter it through her life experience or in the media.  She has no models around her.  We can see the challenges to trusting birth and feeling safe within a low-tech, instinctive birth model.  So where then are American women birthing in the hospital finding their sense of safety?   To what extent is it external? Is it found in the presence of machines? Uniforms? Medical personnel? Medications?

Read more


Birth belongs to women, babies, and families

For the vast majority of our history as a species, pregnancy and birth have been the domain of women. Not women physicians, surgeons, or even midwives — just women! We know, in our collective consciousness, that birth will always belong to women.

The trade union representing obstetricians in the US, ACOG,  continues its smear against midwives and homebirth with regular press releases, garbage science, and other low-brow tactics aimed at securing their financial and medical monopoly over childbirth. Other OB/GYN groups and publications have also jumped in the bad-science ring in an effort to undermine the well-established safety of midwife-attended birth at home. In light of the physician groups’ continued demonstrations that they are threatened by safe, normal, woman-centered birth at home, I’d like to share some images in solidarity with birthing women everywhere.

Here’s to you, birthing women! Here’s to the power, beauty, and dignity of woman-centered birth!

Read more

Birth plan backlash

There’s been a lot of talk lately about physicians responding to their ‘patients’ birth plans by providing a copy of their own written birth plans of what they will or will not do, allow, accommodate, or condone during a woman’s labor and birth. The Feminist Breeder and Stand and Deliver have written recently about the hullabaloo, as have  The Unnecesarean and Crunchy Domestic Goddess. The following is an excerpt from an OB birth plan that was given to a pregnant nursing student during one of her prenatal visits. Just for fun I bolded the parts I thought were the most outlandish and offensive, or simply untrue.

DR. ________ “BIRTH PLAN”

Dear Patient:

As your obstetrician, it is my goal and responsibility to ensure your safety and your baby’s safety during your pregnancy, delivery, and the postpartum period… The following information should clarify my position and is meant to address some commonly asked questions…

* I do not accept birth plans. Many birth plans conflict with approved modern obstetrical techniques and guidelines…. Please note that I do not accept the Bradley Birth Plan.

Read more